Is a Raw Diet Right for Your Dog? Raw Dog Food Pros and Cons

Dog owners want the best for their four-legged friends. That means providing a happy, active life filled with exercise, play and affection, alongside a nutritious diet that supports their overall health and wellbeing. With more owners considering a BARF diet for their dogs, you may be wondering whether raw feeding is the right choice for you.
Before making the switch, it’s important to understand both the potential benefits and risks of a raw food diet. Weighing up the pros and cons can help you make an informed decision about what goes into your dog’s bowl.
What Exactly Is Raw Dog Food and a Raw Diet?
The idea of feeding our best friends uncooked meat can raise the hairs on the back of your neck. Yet raw feeding has been around for decades (or forever, if you ask the wolves!). Since then, raw dog diets have evolved to include more meats, better recipes, and higher standards for preparing, packaging, and distributing the raw food.
Raw feeding diets can be homemade or prepared by a dog food company.
A raw diet is as simple as it sounds and simply means providing your dog with uncooked food. Most raw diets use a whole-prey approach to the ingredients in their recipes. A whole prey approach considers the fact that your dog’s ancestors would have consumed the organs, bone, and stomach contents of what they caught.
Furthermore, contemporary raw feeding philosophies acknowledge the fact that dogs need more than just meat as they are not true carnivores [1]. Rather they’re omnivores that eat a lot of meat, but other stuff, too. This is where the principles behind BARF (biologically appropriate raw food) diets originate. BARF dog foods contain legumes, vegetables, fruits, and other nutritionally necessary components.
No matter if it’s raw, cooked, or freeze-dried, or somewhere in between, your dog’s diet needs to be nutritionally balanced [2].
Why Feed a Dog a Raw Diet?

The biggest motivation for feeding dogs a raw diet is that it reflects the diet pre-domesticated dogs would have consumed. This is often perceived as healthier because it is more natural, and your dog’s body may be better equipped to turn raw food into energy, healthy cells, and more.
Our dogs are adapted to digest raw meat, bone, and uncooked vegetables and have been eating raw meat for much longer than they’ve been given kibble [3]. If you think about it, kibble is somewhat strange. A dog in the wild would never come across cereal-shaped bites that are void of moisture, and would never be exposed to chemical preservatives that become free radicals.
Avoiding unnatural chemicals is a major motivation for many raw-feeding dog owners. Most raw dog diets do not include the chemical preservatives found in dry dog food. Additionally, when proteins, fruits, vegetables, and other ingredients are cooked, some of their micronutrients break down [4].
Finally, many dog owners appreciate being able to control what goes into their dog’s food. This is why many choose to prepare their dog’s diet at home or order raw recipes with limited wholesome ingredients. For a convenient and nutritious option, consider Chick Magnet with Superfood Extras - a premium raw recipe crafted with lean protein and superfoods to support overall health and vitality.
So, What Does Raw Dog Food Include?
Contemporary raw food diets for dogs rarely include just meat. They include a wide array of ingredients, including:
- Meat from muscle
- Ground bone
- Marrow
- Animal fat
- Internal organs
- Egg
- Vegetables
- Fruit
- Yogurt
- Vitamins
- Minerals
Are There Safety Issues with Raw Feeding?
Many dog owners wonder if a raw diet is safe for dogs, and they may have even read a long list of “Why a raw diet is bad for dogs”. You want to keep your pup, yourself, and your family safe while feeding your dog a healthy, nutritious diet, after all. Luckily, when it comes to safety, dependable raw dog food producers take safety precautions to prevent dog owners from being vulnerable to contamination. That doesn’t mean every raw diet is created equal, though.
Most problems of raw feeding arise from mishandling of raw meat and an unbalanced recipe.
Raw meat does contain natural bacteria and microscopic parasites. Dogs’ bodies are adapted with enzymes to kill these contaminants in their digestive tracts. Unfortunately, these microbes can make people quite ill.
What Bacteria Can You Find in Raw Meat?
- Salmonella
- E. coli
- Yersinia
- Campylobacter
- Listeria
-
Staphylococcus [5]
This makes how meat is handled extremely important. First, you always want to purchase your dog’s raw diet from a reputable dog food company. It’s also important to thoroughly wash your hands or any surfaces that come in contact with raw meat.
It's possible for these microbes to be transferred from dogs to kids through a kiss, an unclean dog bowl, paw, or other routes. Children are more susceptible to becoming sick from these microbes due to their still developing immune systems, so, if you choose to go raw, be sure to maintain a "no lick" policy, supervise playtimes, and clean your dog's bowl after each meal.
Can a Raw Diet Lead to a Nutritional Imbalance?
Most nutritional deficiencies arise from homemade raw dog foods. It can be difficult for dog owners to account for every nutritional aspect of their dog’s needs. For example, dogs need calcium and phosphorus, which can be tricky to achieve with a homemade raw diet. This is why using a trustworthy dog food brand developed with a qualified veterinary nutritionist is vital.
The Meaty Truth: The Pros and Cons of Raw Dog Food
So, raw food diets can provide pups with micronutrients not found in cooked foods, but they can also contain microbes that can get people sick. Consider these pros and cons before making up your mind:
|
Pros of Raw Feeding |
Cons of a Raw Dog Diet |
|
Dogs enjoy the raw meat flavour |
Has to be handled properly, otherwise, contaminants can be transferred to surfaces |
|
Filled with micronutrients lost in the cooking process |
Often more expensive than a dry food diet |
|
Provides dogs with the whole nutritional value of ingredients |
Must be stored in the freezer |
|
Does not contain artificial preservatives, flavour, or colouring |
Homemade raw diets can lead to malnutrition |
|
Cleaner ingredients provide dogs with healthy energy |
Excellent choice for dogs with allergies. |
|
Can be an easy way to avoid allergens or ingredients your dog struggles to digest |
|
|
You know exactly what is in your dog’s food |
Is Your Dog Ready to Dive Into a Raw Diet?

Ultimately, it's up to you to decide if a raw diet is within your price range and if the benefits outweigh the disadvantages.
Keep in mind that some store-bought dry dog food can be a source of synthetic preservatives that can be carcinogenic. There have also been countless cases of E. Coli and nutritional deficiencies in popular dry dog food recipes. So whether you're looking for raw or dry, the most important consideration is quality and safety.
If you’re on the fence, adding some raw food to your dog’s breakfast and dinner can help you decide. Raw dog food mixed with a fresh dry food diet can also be a great way to provide your dog with extra micronutrients, flavour, and the organs and bones dogs would naturally consume.
Order your dog’s raw diet from an Aussie brand you can trust. Petzyo’s premium raw dog food is nutritionally balanced and easy to order.
Subscribe now for top-quality raw meals!
References:
[1] https://www.dogfoodadvisor.com/canine-nutrition/dogs-carnivores-omnivores/
[2] https://www.dogfoodadvisor.com/canine-nutrition/dogs-carnivores-omnivores/
[3] https://www.akc.org/expert-advice/nutrition/interesting-things-humans-used-to-feed-dogs/
[4] http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.1069.4205&rep=rep1&type=pdf
[5] https://www.azolifesciences.com/article/Microbes-in-Raw-Meat.aspx

